Sharing Costs
Costs of a regional cooperation arrangement may be shared in several different ways, including division of costs based on:
- Population – division of costs by total number of people to arrive at a per capita rate
- Households – division of costs by total number of households (or occupied households) to arrive at a per household rate
- Assessment value – costs divided according to assessed value of properties in each partner community
- Per unit – costs divided per unit of resource supplied (e.g. water) or waste disposed (e.g. per tonne tipping fee)
- Fee for service – partner providing a service sets a rate for service (pr unit or flat fee)
Governance Models
1. Informal assistance/support (verbal or unspoken agreements)
2. Mutual aid – formal/written
3. Contracts/purchase of service
5. Formation of a joint service provider - incorporated or unincorporated
7. Joint Councils
6. New regional municipal structures - mergers/regional municipalities
7. Legislative options: Regional Councils or Services Boards
Getting Citizen Input
This information will be available soon.
Planning Steps
The Alberta Department of Municipal Affairs suggests the following model in developing regional partnerships:
|
Stage 1 - Opportunity
|
Stage 2 - Parameters
|
Stage 3 - Ground Work
|
Stage 4 - Delivery
|
|
-meet to gauge support for working together
- identify and discuss specific opportunities
|
- negotiate and establish parameters for the partnership, including: scope, governance, delivery, cost-sharing
|
- lay the groundwork for the partnership to function
- set up required systems: may include governance body, obtaining voter approval and an information program
|
- begin functioning/delivering the service
- may begin by commissioning/ completing plans, designs, surveys etc.
|
Source: Regional Partnerships Initiative Guidelines Alberta Municipal Affairs (2004, p.7)
Steps to Success:
- Examine Legal Authority
- Create a Study Group
- Appoint a Drafter
- Be Inclusive
- Proceed in Small Steps
- Allow Sufficient Time for Negotiation
- Circulate a Draft Agreement Among Parties
- Be Flexible and Patient
- Circulate Final Draft
- Obtain Official Approval From Parties
- Share the Credit
- Prepare for Success
Source: Municipal Cooperation and Partnership: Role, Pros & Cons, Benefits, Presenter John Robison of John Robison Inc., Municipal Cooperation and Partnerships Seminar at the AMA Fall Conference (2003)
The “Handbook on Inter-Municipal Partnership and Co-operation for Municipal Government” by the Nova Scotia Department of Community Services” (2003) provides the following suggested steps in the planning process when investigating inter-municipal agreements for service delivery:
Step 1
- Prepare a list of current or previous cooperative arrangements
- Review positive and negative aspects of each arrangement and how it could have been improved
- Determine if it was the most efficient and cost effective way for your municipality to solve the problem
Step 2
Develop an inventory of resources that could be shared with another municipality, including:
- Human resources
- Facilities
- Equipment
- Programs
Step 3
- Determine which of your municipalities might be potential partners
- List pros and cons, possible issues and preferable arrangement in establishing a cooperative
- Determine if potential partners have political authority, motivation and resources to become involved
Step 4
- Research, what have others done
- Prepare proposal with anticipated benefits
- Approach potential partners with proposal outlining pros and cons
- Set meeting
Step 5
- Define problem, need or opportunity
- Identify all stakeholders
- Communication plan
- Contingency planning
- Negotiations
Step 6
- Chain of authority and management
- Procedures for decision making
- Communications system
- Determine rights of ownership
- Conditions for admission or withdrawal
- Cost/benefit review of proposal
- Draft agreement review
Post-project evaluation
Three main areas:
- Conceptually
- Financially
- Administratively
Recognize your accomplishments!
Resources:
Canadian
Background Paper - Best Practices for Moving Toward Change in the Delivery of Local Government Services (June 2005)
Designing Regional Service Arrangements and Service Reviews
Inter-municipal Dispute Resolution
International
QUILT Partnership Checklist: Shaping A Partnership
Checklist for Developing a Partnership Agreement/Contract
Negotiating a Partnership Agreement
A Fiscal Management Checklist for Partnerships
How Are We Doing? A Self Assessment Tool for Partnerships, by the Child Care Partnership Project
"Collaborative Relationships" in Community Partnership ToolKit, by W.K. Kellogg Foundation
Evaluation planning worksheet, University of Wisconsin
Assessing Your Collaboration: A Self-Evaluation Tool
Lynne Borden, Ohio State University and Daniel Perkins, University of Florida